Hot off the jewelers bench, this 2.02 carat round diamond engagement ring is going to make a new bride-to-be very, very happy. And it presented a great opportunity for our client to learn more about diamonds, diamond certificates, and how not all diamonds/certificates are created equal. After bringing in a number of diamonds of various color and clarity grades, he was able to pick the diamond that not only looked good on paper, but one that was also beautiful (and really impressive) to the eye as well.
Let’s go a little further…
Below is a great example of how GIA certificates don’t tell the whole story. Both of these diamonds are G color and they are both graded as having SI1 clarity. I don’t know about you, but I would not be happy if I thought I was getting an SI1 (which by definition means “Inclusions are noticeable to a skilled grader under 10x magnification”) and I got the one on the left. (This begins to explain why diamonds with the same color and clarity grades and similar sizes can have such drastically different prices.)
So what’s the point?
A) Certificates are good for providing more information on a diamond, but they are still subject to the individual grader’s opinion. For example, the diamond above on the left would, in our opinion, be an SI2 – and maybe (just maybe) even an I1. A big black inclusion right in the center of the diamond, visible to the naked eye is not your typical SI1. At the same time, the 2.02 carat shown in the video above is graded as an SI1, but under the scope, it looks a heck of a lot like a VVS2 (meaning it’s probably even a little nicer than it’s certificate says.)
B) It’s important, when buying a diamond, to be able to compare your options side by side. As good as your memory may be, it’s not going to do you any favors when comparing a diamond you saw yesterday to one you’re seeing today.
Have any questions? Let us know!